Sınava çalışmam gerekiyor, Ritalin mi içsem, Concerta mı?

Psikiyatri Uzmanı Çağdaş Yokuşoğlu

            Ritalin ve Concerta ticari isimli ilaçlar metilfenidat
isimli etken maddeyi içeren, dikkat eksikliği ve hiperaktivite bozukluğunun
(DEHB? sağaltımında kullanılan, uyarıcı özellikler taşıyan psikostimulan
ilaçlardır. Bu ilaçları internlük döneminde sadece farmakoloji dersinde değil,
aynı zamanda arkadaş ortamında kullanımlarıyla aşina olmuştum. Bazı
arkadaşlarımız bir şekilde bu ilaçlardan birini temin edip kullanıyorlardı.
Daha sonra psikiyatristlik dönemimde birçok internün benden bu ilaçları yazmamı
talep ettiğini ve onları reddettiğimi anımsıyorum. Ancak yine bu taleple gelen
birçok öğrenciye ilk kez dikkat eksikliği hiperaktivite bozukluğu tanısı
koyduğumu da biliyorum.

            Dikkat eksikliği, vitamin B12 eksikliği, kansızlık,
tiroid hormonlarının fazla üretilmesi gibi tıbbi sebeplerin bir sonucu
olabileceği gibi, DEHB, depresyon, kaygı bozuklukları, uykusuzluk gibi birçok
psikiyatrik durumun sonucu da olabilir. Bu tür hastalık ve durumların sağaltımı
birbirinden farklıdır. Bu sebeple dikkat eksikliğini düzeltmek için bir kişiye
metilfenidat başlanmadan önce bu durumların ayırıcı tanısının araştırılması
gerekir. DEHB dışındaki durumlar metilfenidat sağaltımı etki etmeyecek, hatta
kaygı bozukluğunda durumu kötüleştirebilecektir. Bununla beraber metilfenidat
bir psikiyatrik bozuklukta tedavi edici etkisi en yüksek ilaç gruplarından
biridir. DEHB’si olan kişilerde belirgin düzelmenin görülmesi üzerine halk
arasında söz konusu ilaç mucizevi olarak algılanabilmekte ve bu sebeple
psikiyatri polikliniğine sıklıkla bu ilacın yazılması talebiyle başvurulabilmektedır.
Psikiyatristler ise ilacın kırmızı reçteye tabi olması sebebiyle metilfenidat
reçete etmekte temkinli davranmakta, hatta bazen DEHB’si olan kişileri bile bu
sağaltımdan mahrum bırakabilmektedir.

       YARARI YOK, ZARARI ÇOK

     Yukarıda çizilen tablonun sonucu olarak, önemli bir sınava çalışan öğrenciler (örn. tıpta uzmanlık sınavına çalışan internler, diş hekimliği uzmanlık sınavına çalışan diş hekimliği öğrencileri ve tez döneminde olan doktora öğrencileri) bilişsel performanslarını arttırmak için bu ilacı talep etmektedir. Peki metilfenidat DEHB’si olmayan sağlıklı bir insanda gerçekten bilişsel performansı arttırabilir mi? Öncelikle bu ilacın sağlıklı bir bireyde bilişsel performanıs arttırmak için kullanılması, ilacın kötüye kullanılmasıdır. Ayrıca bu ilacın sağlıklı bireylerin bilişsel performansı ölçen test sonuçlarını olumlu etkilemediği gösterilmiştir (1). Bu sebeple sağlıklı bir bireyin ilacı kullanmak istemesinin mantıklı bir sebebi yoktur. Yararı olmayan bir ilacı kullanmak istemek ayrıca yan etki riskini göze almaktır. Bu ilaçların sık karşılaşılan yan etkileri arasında, uykusuzluk, iştah azalması, sinirlilik bulunur. Ayrıca kısa salımlı format olan ritalinin burundan çekilmek gibi, kafayı bulmak amaçlı kullanımları bildirilmiştir.

İŞE YARASAYDI TAVSİYE EDER MİYDİK?

Peki
bu ilacın bilişsel performansı arttırıcı etkisi olsaydı metilfenidat talebiyle
gelen kişilere psikiyatristler olarak metilfenidat yazmalı mıydık? Tıbbın
birincil ilkesi önce zarar vermedir. Hastalık halinde olmayan birisine, sırf
performansını arttırsın diye, ilaç olarak kullanılan ve yan etkisi olan bir
molekülü reçete etmek tıp etiğine aykırıdır. Ayrıca Sağlık Bakanlığı tarafından
ruhsatlandırılmayan bir durumda ilacın önerilmesi, hekim açısından suçtur.
Durumun bir de eşitlik ilkesi açısından değerlendirilmesi gerekir. Sağlık
hizmetlerine ulaşım, ülkemizde sosyal devletin gelişmemiş olmasından ötürü
eşitsizdir. Böyle bir ortamda sağlıklı bir bireyin, sıralama sınavında daha iyi
sonuç alabilmek adına, bilişsel perofrmansı arttırıcı bir ilaç kullanması,
tıpkı olimpiyatlarda doping kullanan bir atletin durumu gibidir ve haksız
rekabete yol açar. Bir hekimin haksız rekabete alet olması ise kabul edilemez
bir durumdur. Doğru ilacın, uygun durumda, doğru bir şekilde kullanılması
dileğimle tüm okuyuculara ve hastalarımıza iyi yıllar dilerim!

DİPNOT:
S. Batistela, et al. (2016). Methylphenidate As A Cognitive Enhancer In Healthy Young People. . Dementia & Neuropsychologia, sf: 134-142.

Yorumlar

fear of god (doğrulanmamış) Çar, 05/04/2023 - 06:16

I am only writing to let you know of the fine encounter my friend's princess found viewing the blog. She figured out such a lot of issues, which include how it is like to possess a marvelous coaching heart to get many people clearly learn about selected multifaceted subject areas. You actually exceeded people's desires. Many thanks for offering such necessary, dependable, informative and in addition easy thoughts on this topic to Emily.

NathanToG (doğrulanmamış) Çar, 05/04/2023 - 13:50

However autoflowers grow for a shorter period, typically 12-15 weeks outdoors. Either early- or late-emerging weeds produce great proportions of viable seeds that can remain in the soil profiles for a long time period, contributing to the perpetuation and the success of weeds Cavers and Benoit, 1989. Cannabis seeds that are truly worthy of cultivation are likely going to come from black market sources. <a href=https://www.kadenze.com/users/montkush-cbd-oil>https://www.kadenze.com/…;

Timothyusemi (doğrulanmamış) Çar, 05/04/2023 - 18:49

In the ACT it is permissible to possess fifty grams of cannabis dried, or fresh 150g, and grow at least two plants of cannabis per individual, or four plants for a household. Straw, defined here as the stalks and other residues left after harvest of a mature grain, is similar to hay in texture, potential for soil protection and moisture conservation, weed suppression, and application methods. Top Female Weed Strains from Reputable Vendors 2022 s Top Indica-Dominant Weed Strains to Buy in the USA High-THC Cannabis Strains to Grow. <a href=https://www.kadenze.com/users/amsterdam-cbd-oil>https://www.kadenze.com…;

hermes outlet (doğrulanmamış) Çar, 05/04/2023 - 19:30

I precisely desired to thank you very much once again. I am not sure the things that I would've created without the entire opinions provided by you directly on such a industry. This has been an absolute intimidating crisis in my opinion, but seeing this skilled style you managed it forced me to leap with fulfillment. I am just grateful for this guidance and even wish you are aware of a powerful job that you are doing educating the others via a site. Most likely you have never come across all of us.

NathanToG (doğrulanmamış) Çar, 05/04/2023 - 23:25

List of the Best Autoflower Marijuana Strains. This is convenient since male weed seeds or plants must be harvested before they can pollinate the female seeds or plants and block their growth. The seeds make a great snack roasted in the oven, but we can do one better Coat the pumpkin seeds in cannabis-infused coconut oil before roasting them to make a healthy, fall festive edible option. <a href=https://www.kadenze.com/users/green-crack-cbd-oil>https://www.kadenze.c…;

AnthonysTeni (doğrulanmamış) Per, 06/04/2023 - 02:54

The photoconversion of phytochrome in the red light R -absorbing form Pr to the far red light FR -absorbing form Pfr , has been identified as part of the germination induction mechanism in many plant species Gallagher and Cardina, 1998. Frisian Duck created quite an impact when she was first released. example Rumex crispus curled dock -progeny of individual plants vary enormously in ability to germinate in darkness or at common temperature -variation is greater between plants than between habitats, no one germination response Example Xanthium spp. <a href=https://www.kadenze.com/users/cbd-oil-san-antonio>https://www.kadenze.c…;

kyrie shoes (doğrulanmamış) Per, 06/04/2023 - 03:58

I am only writing to make you know of the outstanding encounter my wife's princess went through reading your web page. She even learned too many issues, including what it is like to have an awesome giving mindset to make folks without problems completely grasp several grueling matters. You actually exceeded our expected results. I appreciate you for giving these powerful, dependable, informative and in addition easy guidance on this topic to Ethel.

Ronaldjot (doğrulanmamış) Per, 06/04/2023 - 08:19

This may vary according to the genetics and growing environment, have in mind that it s just to give you an idea of what to expect, some autoflowers may take less and others take longer. Girl Scout Cookies produce a thick aroma towards the end of flowering which may require additional odor control measures. Things to Consider When Buying Cheap Marijuana Seeds. <a href=https://www.kadenze.com/users/cinnamon-cbd-oil>https://www.kadenze.com/…;

Chestermat (doğrulanmamış) Per, 06/04/2023 - 09:11

6 Tension-type headaches can not only originate in the central nervous system but may also be triggered by myofascial tissue, often developing in response to stress. They can grow a maximum of six flowering plants, six non-flowering, and six clones. Present in cinnamon and cloves, it is helpful in treating anxiety, inflammation, and depression. <a href=https://www.kadenze.com/users/best-cbd-oil-for-dogs-with-cushing-s>http…;

NathanToG (doğrulanmamış) Per, 06/04/2023 - 10:54

If you need to relax from a stressful day, release some of that pressure, and maybe even fall asleep, it s one of our top recommendations. The seeds will fall out of the flower head and seed pods and you ll be able to separate the seeds from the waste. Newbie mistakes will be less costly if you only have a handful of plants. <a href=https://www.kadenze.com/users/plus-cbd-oil-gold-drops>https://www.kaden…;

Cliftontup (doğrulanmamış) Per, 06/04/2023 - 12:38

Our future is helping these communities that aren t as lucky as Washington or California and working with groups like WomenGrow who go to these areas that are new and upcoming to the industry and help them set their path forward, she added. Starting with a cannabis clone can save you a couple of weeks to a month compared to starting with seeds because they have a head start on growth. Former Best Indica Cannabis Cup winner Easy to grow Very compact plant. <a href=https://www.kadenze.com/users/cbd-oil-comparison>https://www.kadenze.co…;

supreme clothing (doğrulanmamış) Per, 06/04/2023 - 14:14

I'm writing to make you be aware of what a incredible encounter my child encountered going through your webblog. She came to find so many details, including how it is like to have an incredible coaching spirit to make a number of people with ease fully understand certain extremely tough subject areas. You truly surpassed people's expected results. Thank you for delivering those important, trustworthy, educational as well as easy thoughts on this topic to Jane.

EdmondDoome (doğrulanmamış) Per, 06/04/2023 - 19:51

If you re new to autoflower growing and are looking for an autoflower grow guide or want to know how to grow autoflowering strains, here are a couple of tips to have you growing in no time. When we look at nature, this is not a neccessity. For example, in Alaska, you re allowed to possess up to an ounce of weed and buy cannabis seeds from seed banks. <a href=https://www.kadenze.com/users/cbd-oil-washington>https://www.kadenze.co…;

NathanToG (doğrulanmamış) Per, 06/04/2023 - 20:39

I suspect this glitch has to do with fine print regarding the purchase of fundraiser-specific stock, but I m more than happy to pay full price considering the proceeds go to Duke Diamond s fund. Cons of Jiffy Pellets. High-nitrogen materials include raw manure; white clover Trifolium repens, USDA zones 3 through 10 and the foliage of other legumes, such as peas Pisum sativum. <a href=https://www.kadenze.com/users/super-cbd-oil-300mg>https://www.kadenze.c…;

Cliftontup (doğrulanmamış) Per, 06/04/2023 - 22:14

The SCU is a tool farmers can use to future-proof their weed control system, as herbicide resistance grows and chemistry loses its approval for use. Growers can determine a plant s gender when it reaches its pre-flowering period, which occurs between the fourth and sixth week of growth. The importance of shallow tillage as a weed control method in the false seedbed technique has been highlighted. <a href=https://www.kadenze.com/users/cbd-oil-asheville>https://www.kadenze.com…;

Michaeldeedy (doğrulanmamış) Per, 06/04/2023 - 23:03

5 Best Cannabis Seed Breeders Reviews in 2022 To Get Awesome Genetic Strains. Until the end of flowering, always water them with tap water - pH 6 - although if you stimulate their flowering with an activator like Green Hope, your plants will definitely appreciate that. Errors early in the process can send you on a lengthy wild goose chase until the error is discovered. <a href=https://www.kadenze.com/users/dr-oz-cbd-oil>https://www.kadenze.com/use…;

hermes outlet (doğrulanmamış) Cu, 07/04/2023 - 01:14

I actually wanted to type a small message in order to thank you for all the remarkable techniques you are placing here. My time intensive internet research has now been recognized with brilliant tips to talk about with my family and friends. I 'd claim that many of us readers are really lucky to be in a good place with so many brilliant individuals with useful points. I feel somewhat happy to have used your entire web pages and look forward to tons of more thrilling moments reading here. Thank you once more for all the details.

bapesta shoes (doğrulanmamış) Cu, 07/04/2023 - 09:58

My husband and i were so cheerful when Chris managed to deal with his studies via the ideas he was given from your very own weblog. It is now and again perplexing to just find yourself giving away things which usually some other people may have been trying to sell. And now we fully grasp we now have the blog owner to be grateful to for that. All of the explanations you've made, the easy web site menu, the relationships you make it easier to instill - it is all astounding, and it's really leading our son and our family reckon that this theme is excellent, which is exceptionally essential. Many thanks for everything!

Ronaldjot (doğrulanmamış) Cu, 07/04/2023 - 12:44

Its maximum height is about 16 inches, and it s ready for harvest in about nine weeks. Make sure that the soil you are using for marijuana cultivation is drainable but does not completely drain all the water. Since the feminized seeds have been processed genetically forcing the plant to carry only the sweet sticky female buds we love, it just makes the whole process easier when the pollination aspect has been taken right out for you. <a href=https://www.kadenze.com/users/cbd-delta-8-oil>https://www.kadenze.com/u…;

Chestermat (doğrulanmamış) Cu, 07/04/2023 - 13:36

As for potential effects, these Indica-dominant seeds should make you euphoric, relaxed, and happy, but not particularly productive. Western Gold Mix has golden-orange flowers and is bred especially for the alkaline soils of the western U. There are two major species of crabgrass smooth crabgrass also called small crabgrass and large crabgrass also called hairy or common crabgrass. <a href=https://www.kadenze.com/users/cbd-oil-cannaverda>https://www.kadenze.co…;

Yeni yorum ekle

Bu alanın içeriği gizlenecek, genel görünümde yer almayacaktır.

Plain text

  • Hiç bir HTML etiketine izin verilmez
  • Web sayfası adresleri ve e-posta adresleri otomatik olarak bağlantılara dönüşür.
  • Satır ve paragraflar otomatik olarak bölünür.